Forced to make cruel choices
V. V. Chari is the Paul Frenzel Professor of Liberal Arts in the University of Minnesota Department of Economics and an adviser to the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis.
By V. V. Chari, PhD
In the last five weeks, more than 26 million Americans have filed for unemployment benefits. To put this number into context, note that in February about 160 million Americans were employed. In a matter of a month, well over 13 percent of employed Americans lost their jobs.
These staggering losses are 10 times bigger than anything we’ve ever seen in American economic history in this short a time. And the economic pain is surely just starting.
If current rates persist, we could soon be in a situation where upwards of 30 percent of the workforce is unemployed, a number greater than during the Great Depression of the 1930s. But ignoring the virus could lead to the death of millions of Americans. The pandemic forces us to make cruel choices among unhappy alternatives.
Current public policy can fairly be described as incoherent. The original rationalization for the mass quarantines in which we have engaged was to allow the virus gradually to infect a large fraction of us, in the hope that we would achieve herd immunity. The process was intended to be gradual to prevent the healthcare system from being overwhelmed.
Ironically, the healthcare system as a whole is extremely far from being overwhelmed. This system is now operating well under capacity, with many hospitals facing bankruptcy because they do not have enough paying patients. Despite this evidence, the current rationale is that we will extend mass quarantines long enough to eliminate all infections, or until we find a vaccine. This policy has horrific costs which we are only now beginning to see.
The only sensible solution is dramatically to expand testing capacity, to trace potentially infected people and to isolate them. All this can be done along with a drastic relaxation in government restrictions on economic activity. But the number of tests we are conducting has been stable for a week, with no signs that we are willing to invest in dramatic expansions of testing and tracing. The population most at risk consists of old people, especially those with other comorbidities. The political system clearly puts a huge weight on saving older people, who, as always, seem to exercise disproportionate political power.
It is worth asking every grandparent how much additional risk they are willing to take to ensure a better life for their grandchildren. Let us make no mistake in understanding that the biggest losers from current policies are the bright 18-year-olds whose lives will be ruined if we enter into another Great Depression. Where are the grandparents willing to ask the political system to change its policies?
No matter how the virus turns out, it is clear that the new world that we are creating will be very different from the old one. We will have to get used to the idea that economic activity will shift away from restaurants to home-delivered food, from cruises to remote camping sites, from movie theaters to Netflix and Hulu. Some industries will see decline; others, growth.
The adjustment process will be painful. While this adjustment occurs, we should all anticipate considerable turbulence in our retirement portfolios. The usual advice financial planners give will be even more relevant for retirees: Stay the course and be prepared for large movements in stock and bond markets.
The most important advice for all of us: Maintain social distancing and personal hygiene—and stay safe!
October 2020 Programs
At A Glance
Tuesday, October 13, 2020
Kirsten Delegard, PhD
Tuesday, October 20, 2020
Living Well Workshop
UMRA health plan options for open enrollment
Representatives from the Office of Human Resources
Tuesday, October 27, 2020
Crisis in youth mental health
Kaz Nelson, PhD
The University of Minnesota Retirees Association’s response to COVID-19 developments is aligned with the University's Safe Campus guidelines.
Accordingly, all these events will be held via Zoom.
This year’s annual workshop on the University’s retiree health plans sought to put information about the plans in a larger context. Read more >>
In this sentimental but timely story, the lives of three characters in a small Missouri town merge as they help each other overcome personal loss and hardships. Read more >>
As the University’s 10-year capital campaign enters its final months, UMRA members are urged to continue their generous support of our University, its students, and its essential programs. Read more >>
December 11 is the application deadline for next year’s awards from the Professional Development Grants for Retirees (PDGR) program. Read more >>
Committed to life-long learning and volunteering, musician and global traveler Fran Linhart says, “The U is my best friend. It offers so many wonderful opportunities for retirees.” Read more >>
Lynn C. Anderson and Craig Swan offered a presentation on preserving and sharing family history to UMRA members during a well-attended and well-received Zoom meeting in early October. Read more >>
Amelious N. Whyte Jr., PhD, is director of public engagement in the College of Liberal Arts Office of Institutional Advancement, and previously worked in the Board of Regents office and served as senior associate vice provost for Student Advocacy and Support. Read more >>
Although still teaching and advising in the Program in History of Science and Technology, Sally Kohlstedt is already enjoying the benefits of membership in UMRA. Read more >>
During our UMRA Forum on September 29, 2020, Regent Emerita and lifelong civil rights activist Josie Johnson spoke about the inner strength, spirituality, and perseverance of Black people, and emphasized the need for a brotherhood/sisterhood community where people of all colors are respected and engaged in the fellowship of humanity. Read more >>
Like the classic Black Beauty, in which a horse is the narrator, The Art of Racing in the Rain is narrated by a dog named Enzo. The title of the book is a metaphor for the scary times we face in our lives. Read more >>
Security Analyst Jenny Blaine began our September Workshop with a cautionary note about cybersecurity: You may not think you have anything valuable to steal, but you do. Read more >>
UMRA, together with the University of Minnesota Foundation, has launched a crowdfunding campaign to support the Professional Development Grants for Retirees program. Read more >>
The Professional Development Grants for Retirees (PDGR) program is an annual competition that makes grants available to University of Minnesota retirees for professional development and research. All retirees from all five campuses in the University of Minnesota System may qualify to apply. Read more >>
UMRA held its biannual planning retreat on August 25, bringing together UMRA officers, board members, committee chairs, and interest group leaders for a half-day meeting via Zoom. It was clear from the outset that UMRA has an engaged and vibrant volunteer base. Read more >>
Are you avoiding interesting UMRA programs because you’re unsure how to join a Zoom meeting or attend a Zoom webinar? You’re not alone. But it is not all that difficult. Read more >>
The Bell Museum on the U of M campus in St. Paul is a favorite place for astrophysicist Lawrence Rudnick, and for good reason. Read more >>
UMRA members who want to keep up with events at the University and news about the University can easily do so. There are three news and information sources to which you can subscribe, all delivered by email for free. Read more >>
When Sally Schakel retired from the University of Minnesota’s Nutrition Coordinating Center, she wanted to have a purpose in retirement and to keep connected to the U. She found her “volunteer home” at the University Retirees Volunteer Center. Read more >>
The UMRA News is offering colleagues across the University an opportunity to share with us some of their experiences on being maroon and gold, and Black. Rahel Ghebre, MD, MPH, is a gynecologic oncologist and professor in the Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Women’s Health. Read more >>